WATCH
LUKE 20:1-8
Pastor Scott Andrews
November 8, 2026
LISTEN
READ
Luke 20:1-8
Luke 20:1-8
Some of you are old enough to remember the 1970 rock musical, Jesus Christ Superstar. Even though it’s almost 60 years old, it’s still quite popular. It garnered international acclaim and appropriately, conservative evangelical criticism. It’s frankly blasphemous – to include a flawed and frustrated Jesus, a crucifixion without resurrection, the story told from the perspective of a sympathetic Judas Iscariot – talk about a makeover. Further, once a theater group chose an actress to play the part of Jesus Christ.
The author of the musical’s lyrics, Tim Rice, was quoted as denying the deity of Jesus, but suggesting He was just the right man in the right place at the right time. Which makes no sense – if He wasn’t God in the flesh, then His death meant nothing – and He was in fact the wrong man at the wrong place at the wrong time. Regardless, the show has remained somewhat popular to the present day – a London theater put it on this year with record-breaking summer performances. But you don’t have to fly to London. The London-based company is going on tour in several states next year, to include Greenville, SC this January and Lumberton, NC in June. The musical’s title track, Jesus Christ Superstar, sung by Judas Iscariot, says the following:
Every time I look at you
I don’t understand
Why you let the things you did
Get so out of hand…
There you go. Jesus was a good man, but He let things get out of control – He never intended His movement to be so viciously attacked. He never intended to die, so sings Judas. The song continues,
Don’t you get me wrong
Only want to know
Jesus Christ
Jesus Christ
Who are you? What have you sacrificed?
Jesus Christ
Superstar
Do you think you’re what they say you are?
Are you starting to believe the press, letting it go to your head? Those, you see, are the questions many have. Who are you, Jesus? Do you really think you’re the Messiah – the Son of God? Who do you think you are? Those questions remain to the present day. But they were also the questions asked by the religious leaders of Jesus’ day – who do You think you are? And they weren’t asking nicely. The battle lines were drawn – and those lines still exist today. What authority does this Jesus have over my life? I’m the captain of my own ship, the master of my own destiny. Don’t tell me I will answer to Him one day.
We continue this morning in our study of the Gospel of Luke. We have arrived at the last week of Jesus’ life – the Passion Week – which is the subject of the rock musical. The word passion comes from the Latin meaning to endure or to suffer. I would remind you that while we’re almost four-fifths of the way through the book, combined, a full third of the Gospels covers Jesus’ last week. You see, that’s where the emphasis is – this was the reason for which He had come – to give His life a ransom for many. Please notice – Jesus came to give His life – He didn’t let things get out of hand. He gave His life – they didn’t take it. They couldn’t – He was and is the God of the universe. And Jesus went to Jerusalem knowing what awaited, and yet when He got there, He was the one who threw down the gauntlet.
Well, you remember six months ago in real time, Jesus told His disciples they were going to Jerusalem where He would be handed over to the chief priests, scribes and elders to be mistreated and killed. But, He would rise again the third day. That was the first of three times He told them what awaited when He arrived in Jerusalem. Six months later, they arrive.
Make no mistake about it, it was Jesus who threw down the gauntlet. He pushed the domino over that led to His death. Jesus is the One controlling these events – they didn’t get out of hand. On Sunday, the first day of that final week, Jesus rode into Jerusalem on the colt of a donkey while His followers spread their cloaks and palm branches from nearby trees in His path. All the while, they were proclaiming, “Blessed is the King who comes in the name of the Lord.” The other gospels read, “Blessed is the coming kingdom of our father David; Hosanna in the highest!” This was a fulfillment of Zechariah 9 – the Messiah would come just this way. Who do you think you are, Jesus? He knew who He was.
The next day, Monday, performed a couple more messianic actions. First, while Luke doesn’t mention it, He cursed a fig tree. Why? It was a symbolic action. The fig tree was in full leaf, advertising fruit – there is nourishment, there is food, there is rest. Come and get it. Jesus went and found only leaves – no fruit. It was a case of false advertising. So, He acted out a parable – an object lesson, cursed the tree, and it withered. He killed it. Why? Because it was a great picture of the religious system of the day. The Temple and the religious system of the Pharisees looked good – it promised life, nourishment – meet with God here. But it only had leaves – meaning, while it looked good from a distance, there was no fruit, there was no life of God there. By cursing the fig tree, Jesus condemned their system and promised something else – judgment is coming. But by whose authority – who do you think You are, Jesus? Simply the one who will mete out His judgment.
Next action: He went to the court of the Gentiles and began cleaning house, overturning merchant booths. He drove out all who had made a mockery of the Temple and the Passover – He drove out those who were keeping people from the true worship of God. Why? “My house shall be a house of prayer, but you have made it a robbers’ den.” Judgment had come against the religious leadership – and Jesus brought it. By what authority, who do you think you are? He knew who He was. Which brings us to the next story – the first of several attacks by the religious elite – but one which Jesus easily parries. Look at it with me – Luke 20:1-8.
The religious authorities of the day show up and ask Jesus – by what authority are you doing these things – you can’t do this, who do you think you are? And the battle lines are drawn. By this confrontation, they fired the first shot of the verbal battles that will continue through the chapter. Know that – Jesus will spar with the religious leaders – chief priests, scribes, elders, Sadducees – the other gospels tell us the Pharisees, of course, everyone wanted a piece of the action. They opposed Him – it appears all on that Tuesday. He will conclude this day with a private conversation with His disciples – a conversation we call the Olivet Discourse, chapter 21.
But till then, these religious leaders seek to trap Him, discredit Him, belittle Him. And one by one, they fail. Keep that in mind. They’re trying to catch Him, get rid of Him – they can’t. Not until He allows it. He came, you see, to give His life a ransom for many. That’s who He is – the Son of Man who came to give His life for us, to lay down His life for the sheep. Let me give you the outline of this first verbal battle today:
I. We’ll see The Religious Leaders’ First Attack (1-2)
II. Then, we’ll see Jesus’ Defensive Response (3-4) which actually proves to be offensive, and quite effective.
III. Because third, The Religious Leaders’ Dilemma (5-7)
IV. And fourth, Jesus’ Concluding Touché (8) But is Jesus simply shutting them up, or is there something else here? Does He actually answer their question?
Let’s look at the opening salvo to set the stage. Jesus and His disciples made their way to the Temple complex, probably to the court of the Gentiles that He had cleared the day before – perhaps to the Southern Steps which were the main entrance into the Temple and were called the teaching steps as many rabbis taught there. And notice, Jesus was teaching the people and preaching the gospel. The good news – repent, for the kingdom of heaven is here – it’s available – turn from your sin and in faith to God. This was His consistent message.
Well, as Jesus was there, the authorities approached Him – notice, the chief priests, the scribes and the elders. Does that sound familiar? It’s exactly who Jesus said would mistreat and kill Him six months ago. These three groups made up the Sanhedrin – the official ruling religious, and somewhat political body of the day. There were 71 on the council to include the high priest. It’s doubtful they were all there, but this was likely an official delegation sent by the Sanhedrin to confront Jesus.
The term chief priests is not an official title nor an office held by anyone. Rather, the term was used generally to speak of the members of the priestly aristocracy – Sadducees at this time. We don’t know if they were there that day, but this group of chief priests included Annas and Caiaphas, the high priests who ruled somewhat jointly at this time. It also included members of their families, as well as other elevated priests who served in important positions at the Temple. No doubt, given the nature of the question, the group also included the captain of the Temple guard – who was number two in charge behind the high priest and was responsible for Temple security. Remember, Jesus had just made a mess the day before.
Along with the chief priests came the scribes. The scribes were the experts in the Law of Moses, highly regarded by the people. Last were these elders. The elders were not priests – they were lay leaders, but included Pharisees, Sadducees, scribes – leaders who also served on the Sanhedrin. So, this is an official confrontation, meaning, they start with the big guns.
The point is, these were the religious authorities of the day. They had the legal right and even the responsibility to ask Jesus the question – who do you think you are? “Tell us by what authority are You doing these things, or who is the one who gave You this authority?” You’re not one of us – we didn’t grant you the authority to do what you’re doing. That’s important – they were in charge, and Jesus was not. There is a sense in which they’re saying, what credentials do You have? What school did You go to? Which rabbi trained You? Who authorized You, because You haven’t been authorized by us.
That’s important – they wanted to know the authority behind the things Jesus was doing – certainly that included riding into Jerusalem to such acclaim and cleansing the Temple. But it could also include His entire ministry of teaching, healing, driving out demons, raising the dead, and don’t miss this – forgiving sins. That one really irritated them. Who do you think you are? You have to understand, then, no one acted on their own authority. You had to be backed – you had to have some authority behind you. Who’s behind You, Jesus; what authority do You have?
You see, they had an incredibly elaborate system of ordination. It used to be, before Jesus’ day, rabbinical candidates, those wanting to become rabbis or religious teachers, had to be ordained by a leading, respected rabbi under whose teaching they had served in kind of an apprenticeship. Then, once ordained, when you taught, you would quote your rabbi, giving you authority.
However, as you would expect, this system was open to incredible abuse. By the time Jesus came along, the system had been centralized with the Sanhedrin. While you may study under a rabbi, your ordination, your recognition, your authority ultimately had to come from this council – without it, you were not recognized, no authority. And it really became a good ole’ boys club – it had nothing to do with recognizing those who had the calling and anointing of God. Who has our stamp of approval?
Jesus had no such recognition. All along, His teaching and actions flew in the face of the prevailing authority and system of the day. Remember earlier, the people said, we’ve never heard anyone speak with such authority – because He spoke, not as the scribes, but He spoke with His own authority. He didn’t quote other rabbis. He would say things like this, “You have heard it said,…, but I say to you.” No one said that. Jesus came along, truly I say to you, and taught with His own authority – teachings, by the way, they didn’t like because it opposed their system. Who do you think you are, cleansing our Temple? Throwing out our money changers, our priest-approved sacrifices? On whose authority are you doing these things?
Will you think about that a minute – asking God in the flesh, whose authority do You have? Who’s backing You? Of course, you understand, they didn’t really care whose authority He claimed to have. They knew it wasn’t theirs, they knew He was violating their system – they were only seeking to trap Him, accuse Him, oppose Him, discredit Him, and ultimately, do away with Him. Back at the end of chapter 19, right after He cleansed the Temple, two of these groups – the chief priests and the scribes along with the leading men and began seeking how they might destroy Him. He threw the gauntlet when He rode into Jerusalem the way He did. He threw the gauntlet when He cleansed their Temple – actually, His Temple of their system. Oh, and don’t miss this – they tried to trap Him in the Temple, that is, in front of all the people. People were gathered around, listening, they’re trying to trap Him publicly – that was a mistake.
Which brings us to Jesus’ Defensive Response in verses 3-4. This was classic rabbinic style of debate – answering questions with questions – hoping to arrive at a general consensus or agreement. This was standard procedure. Now, when I’ve looked at this story in the past, I’ve thought – wow, this is great – He answered their question with His own question, and got out of answering their question. They though they caught Him, but He ambushed them. That’s not exactly true – I missed something very important. He did answer their question, with His question. Look at it with me.
When Jesus speaks of the baptism of John, it was a way of referring to John’s entire ministry. We’re not just talking about getting dunked – we’re talking about everything John said and did. You see, Jesus is asking – do you believe what John taught – did you accept His ministry, baptism and all, as from heaven, or from men? From heaven was a way of saying, from God.
The response of the religious leaders? They were in trouble, and they knew it. If we say, from heaven, from God, He’ll ask us, why then did you not believe him? Believe John about what? If we say from men, the people will stone us. They knew they’re in deep trouble – because the people saw John as a prophet. It had been 400 years since Israel had a prophet. John came dressed like a prophet; he spoke like a prophet – he called them to righteousness and repentance like a prophet – they had followed him in hordes. Thousands had come out to hear him, had turned from their sin in repentance, and were baptized. They had finally heard from God through one of His prophets. But, the religious leaders didn’t accept John – they didn’t want to – they had their own thing going. Besides, he hadn’t come through their system either. So now, they found themselves on the serious horns of a dilemma – and they knew it.
So, they simply responded – from God, from men? We don’t know. Remember – they’re in front of the people. They tried to discredit Jesus publicly – Jesus turned the table and discredited them. They were the religious leaders – they were supposed to know. We don’t know – you’re asking who I am – who are you? So, Jesus said, “Nor will I tell you by what authority I do these things.” Notice, by answering this way, He is suggesting He had authority – He just didn’t tell them where He got it. So, He avoided their question, right? Wrong – He gave them the answer by His question. This is the crux of the story.
What was John’s whole ministry about? Who was John the Baptist? Luke 1 told us – John was the forerunner – the one appointed by God to prepare the way of the Messiah – to announce His coming. And he had – behold, the lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world. Behold, there is one coming after me, who was before me, the thongs of whose sandals I am unworthy to untie. In John 1, he says, “I myself have seen, and have testified that this is the Son of God.” John had declared who Jesus was – he had declared by what authority Jesus had come. At His baptism, the voice of the Father was heard from heaven – this is My Beloved Son. You want to know, religious leaders, by what authority, by whose authority I’m doing these things? John told you – did you believe him? No, you didn’t, so I won’t waste my breath telling you what he already had. If we say John was from God, then we will be answering our own question – that Jesus also came from God. That’s whose authority is behind Him. And they couldn’t admit that. The fact is, they didn’t care. They had their own system, their own truth. And so, they dismissed Jesus.
Far from avoiding their question, Jesus answers it so that the honest seeker of truth, unswayed by public opinion, will not fail to see who He is, while those who are only interested in trapping Him will continue to refuse to see the truth. Far from evading their question, He answered them. But when they refused to see the obvious, He refused to state the obvious.
You won’t believe John? You won’t believe My teaching? You won’t believe My miracles? Nor will I answer your question. You must understand, there is a sense in which Jesus said this – since you don’t believe the light of truth – there will be no more light for you. He turned the light of revelation off for them. They willfully rejected the truth they had already heard.
They held their hands over their eyes, they stopped up their ears. We’ve seen it all – we’ve heard it all – and we refuse to believe. And Jesus said, that’s it. I’m not going to answer your questions; I’m not going to reveal Myself to you anymore – you’ve received all you’re going to get. And from this point on, Jesus opposes them, rebukes them, exposes them for who and what they were. In just three days, He’ll stand before these same chief priests and scribes and elders – this time the whole Council, and remain silent. He won’t answer their questions and accusations then, either.
Well, for a time. Finally, in chapter 22, they will ask Him outright, Are You the Christ, tell us? Who do you think You are? Did You let things get out of hand? He will respond,
67 “If You are the Christ, tell us.” But He said to them, “If I tell you, you will not believe;
68 and if I ask a question, you will not answer.
69 “But from now on the Son of Man will be seated at the right hand of the power of God.”
70 And they all said, “Are You the Son of God, then?” And He said to them, “Yes, I am.”
71 Then they said, “What further need do we have of testimony? For we have heard it ourselves from His own mouth.”
You bet you did. I am, and from now on the Son of Man well be seated at the right hand of the power of God. Mark’s account says, “I am; and you shall see the Son of Man sitting at the right hand of power, coming with the clouds of heaven.” The next time you see Me will not go well for you. It will be judgment. No more revelation. I’m not going to walk on water for you, I’m not going to raise the dead for you. You’ve heard it, you’ve seen it, and you refuse to believe it.
My friends, we can’t play games. Jesus has revealed Himself to us. You must decide. You can only plug your ears and close your eyes to truth for so long before Jesus says, no more for you. Some of you come week after week because it’s the thing to do. You hear sermons like this, and you tune me out – you plug your ears, you close your eyes. Hear me – you can only do that for so long. What more do you need to believe? Jesus, who do you think you are? He’s clearly answered. What will you do with the truth? The author of the book of Hebrews says it this way:
7 Therefore, just as the Holy Spirit says, “TODAY IF YOU HEAR HIS VOICE,
8 DO NOT HARDEN YOUR HEARTS AS WHEN THEY PROVOKED ME, AS IN THE DAY OF TRIAL IN THE WILDERNESS,
9 WHERE YOUR FATHERS TRIED Me BY TESTING Me, AND SAW MY WORKS FOR FORTY YEARS.
10 “THEREFORE I WAS ANGRY WITH THIS GENERATION, AND SAID, ‘THEY ALWAYS GO ASTRAY IN THEIR HEART; AND THEY DID NOT KNOW MY WAYS’;
11 AS I SWORE IN MY WRATH, ‘THEY SHALL NOT ENTER MY REST.’”
12 Take care, brethren, lest there should be in any one of you an evil, unbelieving heart, in falling away from the living God.
13 But encourage one another day after day, as long as it is still called “Today,” lest any one of you be hardened by the deceitfulness of sin.
14 For we have become partakers of Christ, if we hold fast the beginning of our assurance firm until the end;
I plead with you to not harden your heart to truth. Who is Jesus? He is the Son of God. They had seen it all, heard it all, and denied it all. Don’t do that. My simple call to you today is to believe the Gospel – that Jesus proved conclusively who He claimed to be. That answer to the questions, Jesus Christ, who are you? What have you sacrificed? Jesus Christ, Superstar, do you think you’re what they say you are? is yes. He is the Christ, the Son of the Living God. And He sacrificed His life for sinners, for you, if you believe.
